The Democratic blowout in the 2026 midterm elections marked the beginning of the 2028 presidential election cycle. Even as antisemitism and hostility to Israel are on the rise in the Democratic Party, reflected in the election of candidates who ran on explicitly anti-Jewish and anti-Israel messaging, six Jewish Democrats are in the conversation about who is running for president in 2028: former Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel, Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker, Georgia Sen. Jon Ossoff, Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, Michigan Sen. Elissa Slotkin, and Colorado Gov. Jared Polis. This fact points to a central paradox: At the very moment that Jews are more concerned about antisemitism among Democrats than ever, Jewish politicians represent a higher percentage of the likely Democratic candidates for president than ever before.
How are we to understand this apparent paradox? And what does it mean for the Democrats, the Jews, and America?
The first possible explanation is that the two apparently contradictory phenomena are in fact related. Namely, the number of Jews in the top ranks of the party fuels resentment and serves as fodder for antisemitism among Democrats who regard these Jews as the lingering ancien régime, which is at odds with the makeup and sensibilities of the party. These Jews in leadership positions are seen as the obstacle to the party fully adopting the new crop's ideological platform and political agenda.
It does not matter how toadyish these Jews are in their attempt to keep with the prevailing orientation of their party. We can see this most notably with anti-Chuck Schumer sentiment among progressive Democrats who seek his ouster as leader. Eight newly elected Democratic senators have said that they would not support Schumer for leader. Though 10 years older than Schumer, Sen. Bernie Sanders, in his capacity as godfather of the progressive cohort, has said that he would oppose the New York senator's return as leader.
Of course, anti-Schumerism can be viewed as part of a broader antipathy toward an aging establishment, characteristic of broader trends in American politics during this decade. See, for example, the vitriol that the insurgent faction on the right directed against former Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell—no Jew he. Even so, Schumer's Jewishness does appear to contribute to the intensity of the progressive dislike of him, just as it may explain Schumer's obsequiousness to incoming Israel-hating Democrats like Michigan's Abdul El-Sayed. Anti-Israel and pro-Iran Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen, who is challenging Schumer for Senate majority leader, accused him of "joining AIPAC" to block El-Sayed's election. As a result of both factors, the next Democratic Senate leader almost certainly won't be Jewish. That said, that person could still serve as the progressives' bête noire should they fail to pass their entire agenda.
The second explanation for the paradox is that antisemitism and progressive Judaism go together. It's not that progressive Jews are antisemitic per se, but that progressivism and antisemitism share the same grievance politics. Antisemites complain that the Jews have too much success or power, while progressives like Sanders think it's the "millionaires and billionaires" (Sanders, it should be said, has adjusted his rhetoric to say just "billionaires," given that many have pointed out that he himself falls in the millionaire category).
Since at least half of Jews in Michigan voted for El-Sayed, it's clear their progressivism—rather than concerns about Israel or antisemitism—is their motivating factor. The cocktail of antisemitism and progressivism is more important than "allyship" with Jews who support Israel. It's been observed that Jews who want to stay in the progressive camp are required to check their Zionism at the door. Many have. The six Jewish presidential hopefuls will be asked, if not to check their Judaism at the door as well, at least to reconfigure their Judaism beyond recognition to correspond to the Jewish-effacing anti-Zionism that has all but become the official party platform. As Michigan's Jewish Attorney General Dana Nessel put it when she called on Jewish Democrats to vote for El-Sayed, "We have a moral imperative to place the needs of the world above even our own self-interest and, yes, even our own survival."
A third possibility for explaining the paradox is that antisemitism is necessary for balancing out the Jewishness of many top Democrats. This kind of balancing might not have been necessary during the supposed golden years of the 1990s, but today the party cannot appear to be too Jewish and still maintain its progressive, intersectional voter base. With Jews seen as oppressors in the intersectional worldview, a party dominated by Jewish politicians creates a cognitive dissonance that progressivism cannot abide. Housing anti-Jewish politicians and policies makes up for the heavy concentration of Jews vying for the top of the ticket.
A fourth explanation for the apparent paradox is that the Jews looking at the presidency are themselves a lagging indicator of what is really happening in the party. The Clinton and Obama administrations were filled with Jewish staffers at all levels, whereas some Biden administration veterans reported a dearth of Jewish staffers at the younger and more junior levels. Arguably, the relative youth of the presidential aspirants mitigates against this theory. If Jews were getting shut out in the lower ranks, the candidates would all be older, reflective of membership in an older generation. While Emanuel and Pritzker are both in their 60s, that's still young for presidents these days. The other four are younger, ranging from Ossoff, at 39, to Shapiro, at 53. Of course, it bears noting that Jewish staffers can presumably continue to populate future Democratic administrations, only they would be hostile to Israel, much like the various Jewish allies or staffers of the rising anti-Zionist Democratic political leaders—a more accurate indicator of where the party stands today, heading into 2028.
This fourth explanation may turn out to be the likeliest, but it may take some time for us to see this phenomenon fully play out. If the next Democratic administration is largely devoid of Jewish appointees who are not staunchly anti-Zionist, or even if applicants to that future administration, like Shapiro in 2024, get asked inappropriate vetting questions about their potential status as Israeli agents, we will see that the plethora of Jewish candidates in 2028 is essentially meaningless. The 2028 Jewish candidates glut would be a temporary phenomenon that is not sustainable in a party actively hostile to Israel and increasingly unwelcoming to American Jews.
Regardless of which explanation is true, the nominal Jewish identity of a candidate is not itself a meaningful gauge of the party's posture toward Jews. Instead, the more immediate litmus test in the party is how that identity relates to Israel, which is to say, to any form of Jewish peoplehood, or Zionism, that's at odds with the party's leftist imperatives.
Accordingly, when the candidates go out on the campaign trail, they may well defend or advertise their Jewishness—though probably in terms that carefully align with progressive priorities, couched in terms like justice (or coupling and equating antisemitism with Islamophobia, as Gov. Polis did in his 2024 statementmarking a year since the Oct. 7 attacks). How they calibrate their positions on Israel will be only slightly more complicated, as the bar for what passes for "pro-Israel" has been lowered radically as a result of the party's metamorphosis since the Obama era, and the degeneration of the national conversation more broadly over the past three years.
For example, all of the aforementioned Jewish Democrats have so far refrained from joining their colleagues who have charged Israel with "genocide"—even if some are like Jon Ossoff, who claimed that Israel "violated the law of armed conflict" and "international humanitarian law." Despite espousing such milquetoast views, most have faced criticism from the left over their demurral on the genocide charge and have adopted similar tactics of criticizing Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (Emanuel traveled all the way to Israel to do so) or "the current Israeli government" or "settlers," to keep up with their party's tendency without having to go further rhetorically.
On the policy level, however, the needle has moved so far inside the party—indeed, inside both parties—that it is now mainstream to call for halting weapons sales to Israel and even for imposing sanctions on Jerusalem over "violent settlers." In fact, it now appears all but certain that the next Democratic administration will use that pretext to sanction Israel. And the Democratic officials arguing for these sanctions are not Democratic Socialists or fringe leftists. They are senior former officials—some of them Jewish—of the Biden administration, which blazed this path in 2024. Just last month, Sen. Slotkin joined legislation to sanction companies and individuals "that help develop Israeli settlements in the E1 area of the West Bank."
That legislation was cosponsored by Sen. Van Hollen, who's vying for the Senate majority leader role. Van Hollen is leadinganother effort to cut the United States-Israel Defense Technology Cooperation Initiative from the Fiscal Year 2027 National Defense Authorization Act, citing "serious concerns" over "the Israeli government's actions in Gaza, the West Bank, and other parts of the region," and he said he fears the initiative "would further increase Israel's leverage over the United States."
The current discourse around military aid to Israel offers more room for maneuver for the six potential Jewish Democratic presidential candidates. Well before, in 2024, Ossoff had already backed Sen. Sanders' push to block certain weapons sales to Israel. Ossoff doubled down in 2025 and again in April of this year, voting with Sanders for measures to restrict "offensive" arms sales to Jerusalem. Gov. Pritzker endorsed the Democrats' 2025 push to block weapons sales, accusing Israel of causing "starvation" in Gaza (a charge also made by Emanuel). Meanwhile, Sen. Schumer was among the mere seven Democrats who did not back Sanders' 2026 resolution.
President Trump's own statements on ending military aid to Israel have provided cover for this position. The more moderate Pennsylvania Gov. Shapiro cited the president's comments on the eve of the midterms to note that the "consensus" in "both parties" now is that "in terms of the aid that we have seen over the last number of decades, I think those days are over."
However, the radical mood in the party is such that even these positions will likely be deemed too accommodating. On both the left and the right, the midterms were framed deliberately as a referendum of sorts on the U.S. relationship with Israel, and on the "Jewish question" more broadly. Heading into 2028, ostensible Jewish Democratic candidates must balance their political aspirations with the ascendancy of anti-Zionism and antisemitism in their own party.

